Rendered at 19:35:35 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
MBCook 15 hours ago [-]
I’ve never heard of Laetrile before. The Wikipedia article on Amygdalin, which it’s a derivative of, covers it well.
A chemical that metabolizes into cyanide, which people climate is a vitamin and “cures cancer”.
What a mess. So much horrible “alternative medicine” hokum out there.
manmal 14 hours ago [-]
I have no idea about this one, but isn’t chemotherapy also quite the toxic cocktail? Scientific rigor back then was also a bit hit and miss. I’m not trying to imply anything here, but your condemnation seems a bit strong.
Turskarama 14 hours ago [-]
Yes, the way chemo works is by poisoning the cancer, but importantly the poisons specifically attack cancer more aggressively than normal cells. Cyanide doesn't work like that at all, it's untargeted and will just kill you without doing anything about the cancer.
LoganDark 6 hours ago [-]
I don't think the poisons necessarily attack cancer more aggressively. Cancer just suffers more aggressively. Subtle difference, but I believe most chemos work by being just poisonous enough to everything (eg by inhibiting cell division) that cancer is the first to die out. Sometimes just barely.
piltdownman 9 hours ago [-]
Zidovudine (AZT) might be another useful analogy.
Dusseldorf 14 hours ago [-]
Which, to be fair, will subsequently kill the cancer.
subsequently indeed. if i had cancer i would rather it be the other way around.
mrheosuper 12 hours ago [-]
If that is your target, a 9mm gun would achieve the same result much faster.
kortilla 13 hours ago [-]
The condemnation needs to be very strong. People fall into the trap of seeing similar things and doing false equivalences like you just did. “I’m not trying to imply” does not disqualify the implication you most definitely made.
Chemo is toxic but it kills the cancer first. That doesn’t land in the same category of things that just kill you.
Evidence-based medicine is the only thing that can split the two and continue to move us away from blood lettings and massaging feet to clear up asthma. It is much newer than science in general so all of the woo needs to be aggressively quashed.
soon_to_be_sb 12 hours ago [-]
>Evidence..
All evidence (second hand of course) is prone to manipulation and censoring.
So "evidence" is just suggestive, not the last word. Acting like it is would just create the same evil, but in a much larger scale (because there is "evidence" or "no evidence"), that you are trying to prevent.
hinkley 60 minutes ago [-]
The practice of science that gives us (or discredits) medicines is the same practice that created the machine you are using to spew this anti-science theory. Smart phones exist as the result of two hundred years of materials SCIENCE progress.
You don’t get from blacksmithing to Moore’s Law without science.
Do you brush your teeth? Have you gotten cavities anyway? Should you stop brushing then? No, because it’s the best thing we know to do. And like a thousand things you do every week without thinking much about, we do our best until we can prove that something else is better. And even then, “better” may be expensive. So it’s still a trade off.
10 hours ago [-]
dylan604 11 hours ago [-]
> continue to move us away from blood lettings and massaging feet to clear up asthma
saying these in the same sentence is funny to me. even if the massaging of feet doesn't clear up asthma, you at least are nice and relaxed. nothing wrong with that even if it doesn't do the claim.
hinkley 57 minutes ago [-]
Opportunity costs.
“Hey it doesn’t cure a heart attack to drink water but at least I’m not thirsty,” is the same sentiment but with more obvious consequences.
myrion 11 hours ago [-]
While bloodletting (with leeches even!) is actually a genuine treatment.
For very specific issues, narrowly applied and supervised with leeches that have been ensured to be disease-free.
That's a far cry from "we don't really know what ails you, probably too much blood", but it's still funny.
hinkley 52 minutes ago [-]
Hemochromatosis patients are advised to donate blood routinely to control their symptoms. And you can lower the amount of heavy metals in your body by donating blood. Though I don’t know if the recipient would be happy to know that.
Knocking people out has many advantages, but only in certain well defined scenarios. Bloodletting was used in mostly the wrong ones, which is why it’s a perennial favorite of rationalists.
kortilla 5 hours ago [-]
You know people can die from asthma attacks, right? Some reflexologist claiming they can cure you so you give up the inhaler and die is what we’re talking about when you pretend alternative medicine is an actual alternative. There is most certainly something “wrong with that”.
genocidicbunny 2 hours ago [-]
That was one of the most absurd dichotomies I encountered. The nurse giving you the infusion walks out with a splash guard, gloved and gowned, carrying basically a hazmat bag that they have to double check and match all the numbers on, and then they just hook it up to your vein and pour it straight in.
masklinn 13 hours ago [-]
> isn’t chemotherapy also quite the toxic cocktail?
Yes. Chemo tries to kill the cancer faster than it kills the host.
While there are/were some Nobel laureates bitten by the quackery bug, laterite origin and promotion has all the requirements of a snake oil being developed by unsuccessful reject with zero credentials and shady biznesses.
pfdietz 14 hours ago [-]
What do they call alternative medicine that works?
Medicine.
somenameforme 12 hours ago [-]
There's lots of stuff that absolutely does have clear clinical benefit but isn't really 'formalized' as medicine. For instance - ginger. And vice versa, there's examples like aducanumab [1] that's an approved medicine, but also doesn't work, and was known not to work when it was approved.
Extremist takes tend to be wrong on most things. On any issue worth debating, there's always going to be plenty of nuance in the grey zone.
You’re confusing corporate greed with scientific/medical rigor.
That we haven’t been able to control the former is being turned into misplaced distrust of the latter.
pfdietz 16 minutes ago [-]
The right wing wants to disparage real medicine not because alternative medicine is better (or even useful), but because they want people to be ok with reducing spending on real medicine.
BoxOfRain 10 hours ago [-]
Dataset of one, but ginger is the first thing I reach for if I feel like I'm going to chunder.
somenameforme 7 hours ago [-]
Traditionally it's also used for cold/flu type stuff both as a prophylactic and a treatment. Works excellently. Or the next time you have a sore throat try a ginger shot. It knocks it right out. I'm not sure how the extremist types reconcile China now having a life expectancy greater than the US even as huge chunks of Chinese still use traditional Chinese medicine. [1]
I'm certainly not arguing that TCM is universally effective (or even mostly effective), but rather that all medical systems have their pros and cons. Western medicine is driven primarily by profit which can result in promoting ineffective medicines and ignoring effective but unprofitable treatments. The outcomes we 'should' have with the idealization of Western medicine are far away from the ones that we do have. Medicine and a profit motive just really don't work well together.
Eh, if only. Medicine is inseparable from business incentives. And since it's a highly regulated industry, they can only cover the costs when something generates a lot of revenue. And there are many reasons why something might not generate enough revenue, even if it works.
dylan604 11 hours ago [-]
It's only medicine if a pharmaceutical company invents it. Otherwise, it's an herbal remedy. It's almost like you know nothing about western medicine.
genocidicbunny 14 hours ago [-]
Much like .45 aspirin, it'll fix what ails you. Permanently.
ikidd 14 hours ago [-]
Behind the Bastards did a couple episodes on the charlatans that have flogged Laetrile. It's a depressing look at the horrendous consequences of alternative medicine not being stigmatized out of existence.
billypilgrim 8 hours ago [-]
This was a fascinating read, thank you. The ending is a lot more uplifting than I assumed it would be. I don’t know how many people today would accept that they have been wrong and positively dedicate the book about their child’s death to the doctor they vilified and dragged through the mud before.
I get angry sometimes about the people in my life who make irrational life-altering decisions based on emotion rather than facts, but I’ll try to remember a lot of people are just deeply scared and either uninformed or misinformed, a dangerous combination.
gostsamo 12 hours ago [-]
reminds me of the british law forbidding any advertisement of cancer treatments. there is a reason why they did it and why it still stands. wish more countries had it.
DonsDiscountGas 8 hours ago [-]
Most countries don't allow direct to consumer ads for prescription drugs. It's just the US and New Zealand which allows them.
MarcScott 12 hours ago [-]
Not just cancer treatments - all prescription medication.
dylan604 11 hours ago [-]
No prescription medication ads? Where would they use all of that slow motion stock footage?
genocidicbunny 2 hours ago [-]
Same place where they'll have to put the speaking-in-small-text narrators that read the side effects at the end of the ads.
nelox 14 hours ago [-]
[dead]
alexcpn 12 hours ago [-]
[dead]
tancop 12 hours ago [-]
I think all of these things should be legal (for adults who use it themselves) if they come with a big ass warning saying its not approved by the FDA and not proven effective. If you see that and decide you want to take in anyway thats on you.
Kayou 12 hours ago [-]
At first glance it seems like a good idea but many people would chose it over a more effective (and more constraining) treatment, increasing the deaths of cancer.
That's often the case with alternative medicine that seems too good to be true.
sdeiley 2 hours ago [-]
Yeah the argument here is that stupid people should be allowed to kill themselves. Not that I agree
margalabargala 4 hours ago [-]
The article is about people who share that opinion and made it legal.
It got more complicated when the toddler got cancer and the parents gave him cyanide instead of chemo.
k0morebi 14 hours ago [-]
Fun fact: over half of all new oncology drugs approved in the US do not work and have no clinical benefit. See: accelerated approval pathway
Best part is these drugs are still released with 100k plus price tags and insurance and CMS still has to foot the bill.
dimavolo 13 hours ago [-]
It’s a philosophy.
Philosophy 1: release quickly, knowing x% does nothing and 0.1x% likely does harm
Philosophy 2: release slowly, knowing 0.1x% does nothing and 0.001x% likely does harm… meanwhile the cancer gets people while they’re waiting.
There’s something to be said for both approaches and obviously both can be calibrated toward less harm and more benefit than they are today.
But ultimately you pick your poison. I prefer the first way.
mlyle 11 hours ago [-]
My philosophy is -- release when there's an argument that there's an x% chance of a net benefit, where x is something more than 50. For most things I'd put the number at around 85%.
There's a reason why most drugs fail trials. that x% and "0.1x%" are big numbers.
Indeed, getting through a trial is still not anywhere near a 100% chance of efficacy.
hinkley 45 minutes ago [-]
Hopefully, a bad cancer drug can only kill 100% of the people who have cancer, but then things like thalidomide exist and harm other people. But setting that aside, the problem is that if one drug fails half a million people and another fails a million, that is half a million people dead because of that choice.
The paradox of choice gets worse when snake oil is added in.
timr 12 hours ago [-]
The piece you're missing is that "Philosophy 1" will cost you huge amounts of money to find out that you got fooled, leaving your family broke when you die.
Also, of course, you rarely know the chance you'll be harmed, but it's almost never 0.1x. Particularly for cancer treatments.
People will reach for the blade of a sword when they're drowning.
marky1991 2 hours ago [-]
I think this is an awfully infantilizing point of view. If someone is dying, who are you to say 'sorry, this doesn't seem likely enough to work for me to let you try that'. If that means they leave their family broke, as a human adult, how is that any of your business. (Now, should insurance/medicare/etc pay for it, that's a different question altogether)
I do concede that 'let rational adults make their own decisions' does lead to unfortunate results when combined with children and I fully support the eventual government intervention in the article, when done only as a last resort and in exceptional situations.
I think the longer-term solution is to figure out why people would cling to crapshoots when something we know has a good chance of working (chemo) exists. People are weird and clinging to things that don't work for reasons i don't understand. But making the government decide what people can and cannot put into their own bodies is in my opinion an immoral imposition (to reasonable extents, you cannot load yourself up with uranium and then walk up and down the street)
mft_ 11 hours ago [-]
[citation needed]
Accelerated approval gets promising drugs to market more quickly (ie without the typically required phase 3 randomised trial) but confirmatory evidence is required later, and the drug should be withdrawn if the confirmatory trial doesn’t… confirm the effect.
3abiton 13 hours ago [-]
Sounds like ship to fail fast philosophy, which probably is useful to test on desperate users.
margalabargala 15 hours ago [-]
It's amazing how some things just are perennial.
This happened in the 70s. 30 years later, Steve Jobs died because he opted for a juice cleanse over chemotherapy. Today, people will take whatever peptide or fad diet their favorite YouTube amateur advertiser cares to shill to them.
Cpoll 14 hours ago [-]
> Steve Jobs died because he opted for a juice cleanse over chemotherapy.
Not quite. He opted for it (it being a great many different treatments, including but not limited to the juice) instead of surgery, chemotherapy wasn't indicated for his cancer. He did opt for surgery eventually, and survived several years longer before remission.
It's a fair bet that he'd have had a better outcome if he had done the surgery immediately, though.
quantumwoke 9 hours ago [-]
I fell down this rabbit hole a few years ago. He had a rare form of cancer, and delayed his surgery by nine months. He did have the option to do something called radionuclide therapy, which is similar to chemotherapy but it seems he delayed that too. We'll never know of course, but starting one of those therapies may have reduced his chance of stage 4 disease.
The main difference between stage 2 and stage 4 cancer is time.
II2II 14 hours ago [-]
You have someone who says they have the cure, and someone else saying they have a treatment that has a 50% chance of success along with some nasty side effects. Who do you think people want to listen to?
It's a perennial thing because people want hope, not honesty.
otterley 14 hours ago [-]
Another key factor is that a segment of people don’t trust “the establishment” (i.e. the science) for various reasons. Some of them even believe they possess special knowledge that is being hidden from them. Those kinds of people are often victims of shysters and refuse to believe they’re being misled and being taken advantage of.
gertop 12 hours ago [-]
There are legitimate reasons to be suspicious of "the establishment", especially in regards to costly and painful cancer treatments.
Sure, you should always be at least a little critical of the establishment, but that isn't a good reason to switch off your critical thinking when someone else tells you they have a different treatment that works. "The establishment is wrong" doesn't imply "anyone who disagrees with the establishment is right".
MBCook 14 hours ago [-]
How much of this is that we even allow these claims in the first place?
Is this a much smaller problem in countries that don’t allow homeopathy or off label/unverified claims?
stef25 13 hours ago [-]
The same hope that your cousin can be the cybersec guy and not that geek who charges 800 / day.
Moral of the story, listen to the experts.
strideashort 12 hours ago [-]
You are essentially saying “if he chose chemo he would have lived”.
That is not established. Many if not most people on chemo die.
margalabargala 4 hours ago [-]
You don't know much about the situation then.
Steve Jobs opted for a juice cleanse, when his cancer was caught so early that with standard care there was a >90% chance of survival.
The juice cleanse lasted long enough that it gave his cancer time to advance to the point where with standard care there was a <20% of survival
RetroTechie 4 hours ago [-]
I'd like to think that Darwin will do its job there.
Over time (multiple generations), people making smart choices will survive more often than people making dumb choices.
But that's an optimistic take - reality is fuzzy.
royraghav28 3 hours ago [-]
the emperor of all maladies is a pretty fascinating read and speaks about laetrile amongst a lot of other baseless "cures" or fad treatments.
hope sells. im sure some guy got valuable b2b insights too
quantumwoke 9 hours ago [-]
I wonder if in 30 years or so a publication will write about hydroxychloroquine or ivermectin for COVID in a similar fashion.
hinkley 37 minutes ago [-]
I know someone who was prescribed topical ivermectin after Covid to clear up their rosacea. It does have its uses, viruses just aren’t them. It works as a paralytic, so I’m unclear how people got to antiviral. But then so much of this is lack of clarity.
Major educational reform is clearly needed but the problem is that these same nitwits are already home schooling to prevent indoctrination.
croes 14 hours ago [-]
> Laevo-mandelonitrile-beta-diglucoside had been around since about 1950, thanks to a father-and-son team in California: Ernst T. Krebs Sr. and Jr.
Pretty ironic given the fact that the German word for cancer is Krebs.
woadwarrior01 12 hours ago [-]
Reminds me of the Krebs cycle in biology, which is named after one of its discoverers (Hans Krebs).
A chemical that metabolizes into cyanide, which people climate is a vitamin and “cures cancer”.
What a mess. So much horrible “alternative medicine” hokum out there.
Chemo is toxic but it kills the cancer first. That doesn’t land in the same category of things that just kill you.
Evidence-based medicine is the only thing that can split the two and continue to move us away from blood lettings and massaging feet to clear up asthma. It is much newer than science in general so all of the woo needs to be aggressively quashed.
All evidence (second hand of course) is prone to manipulation and censoring.
So "evidence" is just suggestive, not the last word. Acting like it is would just create the same evil, but in a much larger scale (because there is "evidence" or "no evidence"), that you are trying to prevent.
You don’t get from blacksmithing to Moore’s Law without science.
Do you brush your teeth? Have you gotten cavities anyway? Should you stop brushing then? No, because it’s the best thing we know to do. And like a thousand things you do every week without thinking much about, we do our best until we can prove that something else is better. And even then, “better” may be expensive. So it’s still a trade off.
saying these in the same sentence is funny to me. even if the massaging of feet doesn't clear up asthma, you at least are nice and relaxed. nothing wrong with that even if it doesn't do the claim.
“Hey it doesn’t cure a heart attack to drink water but at least I’m not thirsty,” is the same sentiment but with more obvious consequences.
For very specific issues, narrowly applied and supervised with leeches that have been ensured to be disease-free.
That's a far cry from "we don't really know what ails you, probably too much blood", but it's still funny.
Knocking people out has many advantages, but only in certain well defined scenarios. Bloodletting was used in mostly the wrong ones, which is why it’s a perennial favorite of rationalists.
Yes. Chemo tries to kill the cancer faster than it kills the host.
Cyanide just kills everything.
https://quackwatch.org/related/cancer/laetrile/
Medicine.
Extremist takes tend to be wrong on most things. On any issue worth debating, there's always going to be plenty of nuance in the grey zone.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Aducanumab#Efficacy
That we haven’t been able to control the former is being turned into misplaced distrust of the latter.
I'm certainly not arguing that TCM is universally effective (or even mostly effective), but rather that all medical systems have their pros and cons. Western medicine is driven primarily by profit which can result in promoting ineffective medicines and ignoring effective but unprofitable treatments. The outcomes we 'should' have with the idealization of Western medicine are far away from the ones that we do have. Medicine and a profit motive just really don't work well together.
[1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Traditional_Chinese_medicine
I get angry sometimes about the people in my life who make irrational life-altering decisions based on emotion rather than facts, but I’ll try to remember a lot of people are just deeply scared and either uninformed or misinformed, a dangerous combination.
That's often the case with alternative medicine that seems too good to be true.
It got more complicated when the toddler got cancer and the parents gave him cyanide instead of chemo.
Best part is these drugs are still released with 100k plus price tags and insurance and CMS still has to foot the bill.
Philosophy 1: release quickly, knowing x% does nothing and 0.1x% likely does harm
Philosophy 2: release slowly, knowing 0.1x% does nothing and 0.001x% likely does harm… meanwhile the cancer gets people while they’re waiting.
There’s something to be said for both approaches and obviously both can be calibrated toward less harm and more benefit than they are today.
But ultimately you pick your poison. I prefer the first way.
There's a reason why most drugs fail trials. that x% and "0.1x%" are big numbers.
Indeed, getting through a trial is still not anywhere near a 100% chance of efficacy.
The paradox of choice gets worse when snake oil is added in.
Also, of course, you rarely know the chance you'll be harmed, but it's almost never 0.1x. Particularly for cancer treatments.
People will reach for the blade of a sword when they're drowning.
I do concede that 'let rational adults make their own decisions' does lead to unfortunate results when combined with children and I fully support the eventual government intervention in the article, when done only as a last resort and in exceptional situations.
I think the longer-term solution is to figure out why people would cling to crapshoots when something we know has a good chance of working (chemo) exists. People are weird and clinging to things that don't work for reasons i don't understand. But making the government decide what people can and cannot put into their own bodies is in my opinion an immoral imposition (to reasonable extents, you cannot load yourself up with uranium and then walk up and down the street)
Accelerated approval gets promising drugs to market more quickly (ie without the typically required phase 3 randomised trial) but confirmatory evidence is required later, and the drug should be withdrawn if the confirmatory trial doesn’t… confirm the effect.
This happened in the 70s. 30 years later, Steve Jobs died because he opted for a juice cleanse over chemotherapy. Today, people will take whatever peptide or fad diet their favorite YouTube amateur advertiser cares to shill to them.
Not quite. He opted for it (it being a great many different treatments, including but not limited to the juice) instead of surgery, chemotherapy wasn't indicated for his cancer. He did opt for surgery eventually, and survived several years longer before remission.
It's a fair bet that he'd have had a better outcome if he had done the surgery immediately, though.
Source; https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC4924574/
It's a perennial thing because people want hope, not honesty.
https://www.oncnursingnews.com/view/less-than-half-of-recent...
Is this a much smaller problem in countries that don’t allow homeopathy or off label/unverified claims?
Moral of the story, listen to the experts.
That is not established. Many if not most people on chemo die.
Steve Jobs opted for a juice cleanse, when his cancer was caught so early that with standard care there was a >90% chance of survival.
The juice cleanse lasted long enough that it gave his cancer time to advance to the point where with standard care there was a <20% of survival
Over time (multiple generations), people making smart choices will survive more often than people making dumb choices.
But that's an optimistic take - reality is fuzzy.
hope sells. im sure some guy got valuable b2b insights too
Major educational reform is clearly needed but the problem is that these same nitwits are already home schooling to prevent indoctrination.
Pretty ironic given the fact that the German word for cancer is Krebs.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citric_acid_cycle
whoa, that's cray(fish)