Rendered at 18:47:55 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time) with Cloudflare Workers.
JSR_FDED 4 hours ago [-]
This entire thing is a strange parallel universe for me. What are Tranco, Majestic, Faviconese? What is tapping on a website while forgetting it’s a website? Which 3-day exploit chain of doom?
Frotag 4 hours ago [-]
"tapping on a website while forgetting [the side-effects of tapping a] website"
is what he means. The phrasing is a bit of an idiom and isn't meant to be taken literally.
Anyways I kinda like the flippant(?) tone of the OP, wonder if there's a better term to describe this type of writing. Best I can think of is "halfway between image-board speak and casual speech".
zenoprax 2 hours ago [-]
The AI disclaimer at the end describes their prose as "jackslop".
I like it.
bilkow 1 hours ago [-]
Just to be clear, in my understanding they describe the manual part of the process adapting the references from the original site (to make them look like responsive images) as "handcrafted artisan jackslop", not necessarily their prose.
2 hours ago [-]
timcobb 4 hours ago [-]
AI gonzo?
ChrisMarshallNY 3 hours ago [-]
I think it would not be difficult to instruct an agent to write all its prose in the style of Hunter S. Thompson.
jsisto 3 hours ago [-]
I struggled to produce this with gpt-4
holdupagain 2 hours ago [-]
Try giving it mescaline.
ChrisMarshallNY 2 hours ago [-]
Ether might do it...
ChrisMarshallNY 3 hours ago [-]
Too gonzo?
Maybe Grok would be better. It's halfway there, already.
tygon 1 hours ago [-]
Fear and Loathing in Web 3.0.
stonedivot 3 hours ago [-]
It's called "creative writing". A soon to be lost art I'm sure.
mxmilkiib 3 hours ago [-]
shocking to think that writing styles people are unfamiliar with are now being labeled AI
creatonez 2 hours ago [-]
It's called being tapped in and witty as fuck
antonvs 4 hours ago [-]
> a better term to describe this type of writing
"Terminally online"?
plorg 3 hours ago [-]
Being linguistically entrepreneurial is not new or unique to the internet.
antonvs 2 hours ago [-]
It’s more the specific vocabulary.
plorg 1 hours ago [-]
The specific vocabulary references Internet things because he's talking about things that specifically exist on the Internet.
smallmancontrov 3 hours ago [-]
These days, that phrase usually describes kids watching twitch streamers or scrolling tiktok, not people who obsess over backlinks, DNS, and security patching in the age of cyber-capable AI.
217 3 hours ago [-]
Personally I'm doing all of these
CarlitosHighway 3 hours ago [-]
Flippant is one word to describe it. Vacuous is another.
suzzer99 4 hours ago [-]
Faviconese just means he looked at the favicons to determine that they were gambling sites.
pqs 4 hours ago [-]
That's how I feel reading Hacker News since AI. People in a different universe are using the site now.
egeozcan 3 hours ago [-]
I sincerely do not understand what you mean. What seems so different for you to say that?
Maybe it's a frog in a slowly heated water kind of thing, me being the frog, AI the slow heat.
acomjean 2 hours ago [-]
There is a lot of ai terminology. It starts getting weird if you are unfalliar. (Quen, deepseek, hugging face…)
Tranco (from Gemini): "Tranco is a research-oriented, manipulation-hardened top one million website ranking list designed to fix reproducibility and methodological flaws in older popularity metrics like Alexa."
The other... No idea.
derefr 3 hours ago [-]
Sibling comments covered the other stuff, but I'll clarify the particular "strange parallel universe" this article exists in: it's investigative web security / web-forensics journalism. And not the kind written by general-beat journalists, re-digested for a general "pop science" reader; but rather, the kind written by people who do such investigations themselves (whether they did the particular investigations they report on, or are getting the information from their trusted sources and contacts in the web-security community.)
This type of ingestigative web-security writing has three audiences:
- the "general" audience of non-security-focused IT professionals, who are nevertheless interested in security topics from afar;
- the "professional" audience of other web-security professionals, who do the exact same kinds of investigations the author themselves does (whether or not they then share their results publicly);
- and the "oppositional" audience, i.e. the very malicious-actor groups the investigations target.
Each article thus serves three purposes:
1. to the "general" audience, the article provides an entertaining and informative journalistic narrative (and this encourages this group to spread the article, to increase the likelihood people in the other two groups will read it);
2. to the "professional" audience, the article serves as an "investigation log" that must provide enough information to reproduce the derived information (so that the results can be trusted and acted upon), and/or so that the investigation can be taken further without wasting time doing things that have already been done (because each piece like this, if it doesn't end in the investigation target being cleaned up, serves double-duty as an invitation for collaboration, either directly, or via encouraging independent "federated investigations");
3. to the "oppositional" audience, the article acts as propaganda for the power and reach of the "side" of the investigators, with the intent of producing chilling effects against others doing the same thing; and, more specifically to would-be collaborators with the target group, acts to scare them off from doing that, cutting off the target group's resources.
Note the three-way conflict-of-interest this introduces: security professionals need to know how and where you got your information; general audiences don't really care and just find such info to be needless detail; and your investigation targets should ideally know as little as possible about these tools, so that they don't start enacting countermeasures to make these tools useless against them. (But it's good that the opposition is aware that these tools exist and understand the chain of inputs and outputs that goes through them -- to show exactly the sloppiness that got them got, and so prove that web security people are not just bluffing about having such powerful tools while actually parallel-reconstructing info they get via e.g. double-agents.)
This conflict-of-interest is mostly resolved by just naming these tools while describing them as little as possible, and absolutely never linking to them.
Security professionals are expected to recognize the names and know how to get access to them (if they don't have it already); general audiences are expected to just gloss over these names as some kind of technobabble (an expectation you and I, being curious-by-nature people, failed); and the opposition is expected to recognize that these tools exist, but either struggle to find them (these tools are often referred to by nicknames that are also names of larger services in other domains, so just punching the tool's name into google often does nothing), or struggle to get access to them. (With a specific additional goal of minimizing the knowledge the opposition has of these tools so that they can't socially-engineer their way into convincing some bureaucratic employer that they "should" be given access to them. Which means never describing how these tools work, providing screenshots of them, etc.)
isolay 2 hours ago [-]
All the commenters in this thread are Faviconese.
cbm-vic-20 3 hours ago [-]
Curtains for Zoosha?
ryandrake 1 hours ago [-]
Searched for this so I didn't have to link to the original meme [1].
The author seems to like style over substance, buzz words over clarity. To me a fail-safe sign for a low IQ.
VladVladikoff 3 hours ago [-]
Seems unnecessarily harsh.
jcattle 2 hours ago [-]
The commenter seems to like insults over constructive discussion. To me a fail-safe reason to flag and downvote.
OgsyedIE 4 hours ago [-]
To quote a terrific novel:
"The president of agalmic.holdings.root.184.97.AB5 is agalmic.holdings.root.184.97.201. The secretary is agalmic.holdings.root.184.D5, and the chair is agalmic.holdings.root.184.E8.FF. All the shares are owned by those companies in equal measure, and I can tell you that their regulations are written in Python. Have a nice day, now!"
ajcp 4 hours ago [-]
For those (like me) not familiar: Accelerando by Charles Stross, published in 2005
Interestingly, it predicted the presence of mass AI robocall scams targeting the elderly almost a couple decades before it happened.
noduerme 4 hours ago [-]
man, the first sentence is just so... Snow Crashy. I kinda miss whatever we were all amped up on in the 90s.
GolfPopper 3 hours ago [-]
Hope for a better world.
Not much of that going around these days.
OgsyedIE 3 hours ago [-]
Most of the members of the human race in Accelerando die prematurely and painfully, tech firm employees included, fwiw
lopsotronic 53 minutes ago [-]
Young folks don't quite grasp[1] just what and how much we lost after 9/11. The 1990s were a very special time.
Go soak in some culture, music videos and such, from the era. I watched the video for Beck's "Sex Laws" recently, and was overcome with the realization of what a hopeful time it actually was. The 1990s idea of a dystopia was something like Ellis' Transmetropolitan, a dystopia that looks frankly awesome as hell, in retrospect.
Unfortunately, in 2001 the boomers were still very firmly keeping their lead-brain-addled grip on the tiller, and they set a course straight for national disaster. As Osama predicted they would. But did he realize that would be handing the keys directly to the Chinese? Oops? Whelp that's the problem with extremism - it gives you tunnel vision of the worst sort.
[1] Perhaps it is a different shade[a] of the same feeling that even older people of a certain culture have for the pre-Desegregation era. "Let me tell ya back before all that stuff things were a lot nicer. . . "
[1.a] Different shade, except Evil.
nonethewiser 21 minutes ago [-]
Respect your elders
antonvs 3 hours ago [-]
It was about imagining what the future might be like instead of actually experiencing it. Even the dystopias in those novels were exciting. But we ended up with a boring dystopia instead.
We could still get the Gibsonesque "AI fighting for control" plot though. Perhaps in January, the Democrats could rebrand ICE as the Turing Police. Not that I'm in favor of that, but at least it would be more interesting.
motbus3 3 hours ago [-]
Elderly people having been victims of phone scams since phones exist
yboris 1 hours ago [-]
Accelerando is one of my all-time-favorite sci-fi novels. In part inspired me to write my own sci-fi novel (WIP)
UltraSane 4 hours ago [-]
This novel is amazingly prescient.
bloke_zero 3 hours ago [-]
This year 70% of my reading has been Stross - discovering him this year was super refreshing - which started by following him on Mastodon - viva the fediverse!
whh 4 hours ago [-]
It was created 2026-11-11 at Cloudflare. Given the huge number of backlinks, I'm wondering if it's part of Cloudflare's Bot Fight mode or Cloudflare Turnstile related feature.
It could be an interesting way to observe if certain crawlers are obeying robots headers by analysing scraped content, or could just be some element on the page itself and part of turnstile.
If it was registered by the Cloudflare team, they might explain why.
nonethewiser 3 hours ago [-]
Bot posted spam in comments and forums, or a widely used website template or widget? Paying for the referrers would give more info.
Something interesting is that the domain was unregisters for a very long time after it was referred to.
- It was in Majestic's top 10,000 in since October 5th before peaking to 8 recently.
- It was unregistered for almost that entire duration. Someone in Arkansas (self-reported WHOIS address) bought it through Cloudflare on Nov 11, and it still doesn't point anywhere. Could be a different person who noticed it was popular and bought it.
- About 250M links come from roughly 5M sites, including thousands of .edu and .gov sites. Nearly all are nofollow and on inner pages.
- Majestic's top link texts are the Chinese "打开这个网站 →" ("open this website →") and "↗ (opens the site in a new tab)". And about 67% of linking pages are in English. Suggests the links were of Chinese origin, not written by the sites themselves. And perhaps site rules dictated noreferrer.
- The count is now falling, and 23% of the links are already deleted, so it's being cleaned up (deleting forum posts?).
nonethewiser 3 hours ago [-]
The Chinese language and referrer are probably bad signals. I checked on Semrush and found a kind-of Chinese mirror of Majestic as the origin for that.
That leaves:
5.2M linking sites, nearly all nofollow, mostly on inner pages, many repeated within a site, about 21K .edu and .gov domains, and a falling total.
Semrush did show recently created links. Those were on spammy looking sites akin to 1289371298.xyz with copy like "education site link building" which sounds like it's just referring to a sketchy SEO practice of getting quality referrers. I think those websites are basically echoing the signal as well - they just find links that are common. Not the original source.
The weirdest part is that it was unregistered for so long. Was that a mistake? Was the w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a domain name a mistake?
RugnirViking 2 hours ago [-]
the "top link text"s come from a sample of just 6 links, I think automated summaries of the blog post and this hacker news page
nonethewiser 2 hours ago [-]
yes, you are right. bad signal there. You can get a limited view on semrush and I saw recently created ones which were on junky looking domains like 1289371298.xyz with copy like "education site link building" which sounds like it's just referring to a sketchy SEO practice of getting quality referrers. That was a very small sample size though - couldn't see much on free tier.
I think those websites are basically echoing the signal as well though - they just find links that are common. Not the original source.
caminanteblanco 4 hours ago [-]
For anyone else who loves the author's style, they wrote a really great article a while back where they installed every firefox extension: https://jack.cab/blog/every-firefox-extension
The NS records point to aryanna.ns.cloudflare.com and peyton.ns.cloudflare.com. Cloudflare issues a unique pair per account, so if there is another site with matching NS records they belong to the same account/owner.
edit: Not definitive but a potential signal
> The default assignment method is to use standard nameservers and favor consistent nameserver names across all zones within an account. Nonetheless, in case there are conflicts, you may get different nameserver names, even for domains that are within the same account.
> so if there is another site with matching NS records they belong to the same account/owner.
Not definitively. There are only so many pairs, many tens of thousands of customers probably call the same set home.
bigbuppo 50 minutes ago [-]
I have two different pairs on my account. Turns out if you register a domain and set its nameservers to the pair you normally get before adding it to cloudflare they'll assign it to a different pair!
QuantumNomad_ 3 hours ago [-]
I was wondering at one time why the name servers of my domains in Cloudflare had specific names (instead of say ns1 and ns2), while it was always the same two for all my domains. But I never connected the dots and guessed that the Cloudflare name servers were assigned per account. TIL!
benleejamin 4 hours ago [-]
Curious about the backlinks monitor… does anyone have a rec that htey like?
open-paren 4 hours ago [-]
I wonder if it is the killswitch address for a botnet
breakwaterlabs 4 hours ago [-]
Almost certainly campaign / malware related.
breakwaterlabs 4 hours ago [-]
Looks like actual- or aspirational- c2, attempting to use aging and popularity metrics to evade blocklists which frequently rely on those signals as proxies for trust.
changing w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a to xn--w2rt6byl5nf1opmc does get 帉垛墐嗃堣岜 which is apparently gibberish - maybe there's an ad botnet getting a corrupt address?
dhosek 4 hours ago [-]
Given that ratings are by backlinks, and from my experiences battling linkspam on a mediawiki site, I would guess that it’s a site that was directed to by backlink spam.
stanac 4 hours ago [-]
Once I got attempted sql injection in referer header. It didn't work, not sure who is trying such things and why.
xmcp123 3 hours ago [-]
Sites that have poorly made local analytics setups
IggleSniggle 3 hours ago [-]
Well, now that this is being discussed, and folks are about to widely figure this out, I guess I can conjecture from my own background.
Before quitting ad-tech, I determined that, with IP addresses being hidden (eg the way Private Relay does), something like a large DNS backmap would be the only way to effectively determine that a visitor was a returning one across network sessions, because you need some signal that the user does or does not already "know" the destination on their first visit. At that point, it's kind of up to the DNS servers (esp the ns) to determine if this is abuse or not; but if they allow it, you can get a reasonable proxy for IP identity.
I don't have any good solutions in terms of maintaining privacy, except the known existing one, and how it's already supposed to work (which would have made hiding IPs unnecessary in the first place). I'm afraid it's too technical for most people who just want to connect and watch YouTube shorts or whatever: federated trust, with each smaller subset refusing to link through to any identifying information about their subset of users.
Feel free to DM me if you've got a job for me to help make it happen. I've got plenty of other valuable work to keep me busy, but I'd be interested to know if someone is working on this problem.
caust1c 3 hours ago [-]
Not sure I follow precisely, but couldnt dns adblockers simply block the backmapping domain?
IggleSniggle 3 hours ago [-]
This presumes a participating domain that you "wanted" to visit forwarding your identity, somewhat like CNAME wildcard shadowing.
narag 3 hours ago [-]
This reminds me that, a couple of years ago, I was searching for an obscure name and landed on a strange set of pages. They were distributed along a few domains. IIRC it was the same domain name with different African TLDs. There wasn't much in each page, except links to other domains in the group. I gave up trying to understand what purpose it served, but the TLD detail made me suspect it was some sort of experiment to play search engines.
jubilee33 3 hours ago [-]
Probably someone read about marketing web-rings and put an effort to build one but never populated it with content? In the days before llms making/gathering the content was the big work involved.
Dwedit 4 hours ago [-]
Domain.glass says it's a domain hosted by Cloudflare. I wonder if there's some kind of weird quirk or issue where it thinks that anything from Cloudflare resolves back to that name?
bloak 3 hours ago [-]
The first 16 characters look to me like random lower-case letters and digits. Decoded as base 36, with either digits first or letters first, it gives a number with 83 bits and still looks random to me.
With the 'w' and the '1' in there it doesn't look like base 32.
neuroticnews25 2 hours ago [-]
Also it's without repetitions.
bloak 2 hours ago [-]
The probability of 16 randomly chosen characters from an alphabet of 36 characters containing no repetitions is ... about 0.019? So I suppose that's marginally significant? Or would be if we could think of a plausible way in which strings without repetitions might have been generated?
card_zero 3 hours ago [-]
https://www.ic.work/article/the-false-digital-factory-of-seo is an article that claims "The case of w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a.com shows a modern SEO technique that doesn't require malware or even real web content. It just takes advantage of indexing tools blindly trusting the number of backlinks."
So "Some loophole/gaming the rankings".
Caveats: this article is a reaction to the jack.cab post, not earlier than it. It also repeats itself a lot in a slop-like manner, so it might just be some LLM's answer.
0x00cl 4 hours ago [-]
Well, the subdomains look like MD5 hashes.
I tried a few wordlists to see if any word matched those md5 (rockyou.txt) but didn't match anything.
letrix 4 hours ago [-]
> I used a chatbot to convert four screenshots to HTML + CSS, to make the article responsive
[Scrolls back up again]
No way
Though the Discord one isn't fully responsive. It overflow on mobile.
Am I having a stroke? I don't understand a single thing
xyzzy_plugh 4 hours ago [-]
The comments here are strange, but surprisingly few of them are trying to answer TFA's question:
What the fuck is w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a.com?
Seriously. We're on this website, a website frequented by all kinds of experts at internet infrastructure companies: ISPs, CDNs, Google, Cloudflare.
Consider this your Official Monday Morning Coffee Nerdsnipe. I expect an answer on my desk by the end of the day.
stonedivot 3 hours ago [-]
I highly doubt that, these days, those are the kinds of experts visiting this website. And if they are, there's very little left of the hacker mindset. This is basically Reddit-lite.
IAmGraydon 1 hours ago [-]
The hackers are still here, but the population of the low-quality posters has grown much larger than it used to be, so the signal to noise ratio is low. You see a lot of replies now where people are just trying to make the most idiotic/formulatic joke possible for upvotes. That is definitely something you see at Reddit and something you never used to see here until recently. I really wish DanG would have implemented some kind of vote-to-ban mechanism before it got this out of control as it's clearly impossible for him to police by himself.
Dove 1 hours ago [-]
I had the same thought. I came here expecting incisive analysis, and while I found some pretty far down the page, I found a mix of dismissive and curious confusion in all the top comments. The top comment can't figure out "Faviconese" or follow a witty commentary on the danger of clicking strange links. Really? Confusion about creative expression? As the topcomment? "Oh right," I thought, "it's 2026. I guess that's how far things have fallen."
And then it hit me that I've been coming to this web site for seventeen years and that things change over time.
And I'll admit, society as a whole seems to have taken a turn for the worse in this department. There was a time when merely being online was something of a filter, and knowing about HN definitely was. Alas, walls being free is a special case. They usually have to be built. In the absence of catechesis, creed, peer review, editorial board, secret handshake, something, the masses draw a culture to the mean.
Edit: In the hour since I last looked, the intelligent crowd I expected seems to be showing up in force. Perhaps it was a fluke. I'll put away my doomsday sign about how the robots and the zombies are coming. They are, though.
caust1c 3 hours ago [-]
Nonsense, theres literally dozens of us still here! XD
nonethewiser 3 hours ago [-]
Developed by Chinese language speaker(s) and spread to English language speakers.
whynotmaybe 4 hours ago [-]
As we're all professionals with a lot of experience, is "I don't know" a valid answer? And could you please create a Jira ticket about it so that my team can look into it?
Rooster61 4 hours ago [-]
Jira is down. It was on the instance running behind w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a.com. You didn't get the email from IT stating as such due to the Outlook outage.
skrebbel 4 hours ago [-]
The opening paragraph made my day.
TheSkyHasEyes 4 hours ago [-]
I liked this.
> I could probably figure out what’s happening here in 30 seconds by buying a Majestic subscription but I’m lazy.
They're not interested in spending money on this. I wouldn't be either.
w4yai 4 hours ago [-]
I find the whole "I'm so smart I'm lazy" attitude to be quite childish to be honest
bigfishrunning 4 hours ago [-]
Yeah I feel like successful people grow out of that very quickly. Turns out laziness isn't very smart if you're paying attention to the results of your actions.
RIMR 3 hours ago [-]
I think you're failing to get the joke.
If he could solve this in 30 seconds, it's not exactly lazy to then do the hours-long investigation he did.
He's joking about being lazy, because he's being cheap.
Also, there's nothing wrong with using "laziness" as a motivator for making things more efficient, as long as you're doing it right, however "childish" you consider that wording.
tefkah 4 hours ago [-]
love your writing style op very fun
0912636410 2 hours ago [-]
This is classic doorway behavior. Many people here won't recognize the term because it's what we called it in the 2000s, before platforms like SemRush rebranded mass-generated landing pages as 'Programmatic SEO' (pSEO) to make the same underlying tactic sound white-hat.
mixtureoftakes 3 hours ago [-]
Most whiplash i've experienced from a personal website this year. Good job
bongofizzbuzz 4 hours ago [-]
There are youtube videos with blank titles or very weird names that can never be searched
4 hours ago [-]
4 hours ago [-]
LastTrain 1 hours ago [-]
I don't know what the fuck is w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a.com either but I love almost everything about that blog post.
fleebee 4 hours ago [-]
This post felt a little incomplete and incoherent. I don't think I learned much from reading it.
assimpleaspossi 4 hours ago [-]
Any title with vulgarity in it for the sake of vulgarity is usually one hint of that.
devmor 4 hours ago [-]
My first thought was that it looks like something encoded from something else. Like how punycode domains with xn—- appear.
janandonly 4 hours ago [-]
That's what I thought too.
pryanshu89 4 hours ago [-]
[dead]
ivanmontillam 4 hours ago [-]
I thought it was one of those predictable network device names.
Rooster61 4 hours ago [-]
It's things like this that make me feel like cracks are forming in the internet; cracks that we can't just plaster over with a bit of Javascript, spit, and prayers like we always have. It's like it's sagging under the weight of what both humans and bots are trying to make it do and it just wasn't designed for this kind of madness.
willmadden 3 hours ago [-]
Something that shouldn't exist, exploitation of backlink ranking. Call the internet police!
VladVladikoff 3 hours ago [-]
But they never even registered the domain. Seems more like some glitch in a blog spam comments bot, or just a joke by someone to see how much they could push a domain up the SEO charts with blog spam comments alone. They gave it an extremely unique and random name to avoid any bleeding over from other possible typos in links etc.
It also could be an experiment to see how classic search engines and AI search handle ranking websites who’s main backlink profile is no-follow. Actually this is probably the most likely explanation, it also explains why they didn’t even register it and put content, they wanted to see how a domain ranks from those no follow links and didn’t want the content to pollute the signal.
ChrisArchitect 3 hours ago [-]
hard to say but probably some random string domain being called by a certain router, network card brand or IoT device network (TV?) for testing connectivity or something as in example.com etc and so a ton of hits being registered.
2 hours ago [-]
squidmaster 4 hours ago [-]
[dead]
debo_ 4 hours ago [-]
I'm waiting for the day for the "aggrieved millenial" voice to die out completely as a writing style.
voidfunc 4 hours ago [-]
What ever comes after will be worse considering Gen Z is barely capable of forming sentences.
We're doing just fine, old man. Some of the smartest people I met so far were from my generation. The oldest zoomers are about to start turning 30. Yet you go online and see nothing but enraged millennials grinding their teeth in their common hatred of many tens of millions of people. Of course, you all are without an exception a divine gift to humanity, while everyone born after you can barely remember to keep breathing. You're just so good.
thousand_nights 3 hours ago [-]
lil brooo low key deployed to prod :skull: :skull:
iLoveOncall 4 hours ago [-]
[flagged]
tygon 1 hours ago [-]
I liken it to writing you might find in low budget urban legend videos you would watch at 2AM. It is meant to build intrigue and be there "along with the writer" as events happen, putting you in their shoes as the mystery reveals itself.
OgsyedIE 4 hours ago [-]
It's entirely 100% readable to me, in the sense that the ordering of paragraphs and rich content forms a consistent essay throughline.
Unless your perception is the trivial case (e.g. Ashby's law or categorical empty interpretations) I'd be very interested to know why our linguistic experience differs so much.
eitally 3 hours ago [-]
I truly do not understand such a strong reaction. Maybe it's because I'm old, or maybe just generally well-rounded, but I had no trouble reading this at all. Moreover, it was engaging and the mystery is intriguing, and now I'm curious about it, too. Heck, the author even included a small glossary at the end.
gspr 4 hours ago [-]
Another datapoint: I also struggled reading it. But I enjoyed it a lot more than slop.
mixtureoftakes 3 hours ago [-]
It's really hard to read it's just unusual which requires focus, and in turn is much more enjoyable
gspr 3 hours ago [-]
Agreed.
runxel 4 hours ago [-]
Don't mind the (unwarranted) downvotes my friend – I couldn't read it either.
The endless, unexplained slang didn't help as well. There is no structure, no nothing. Is it still better than ai slop? You bet.
neuroticnews25 3 hours ago [-]
I could read it and I don't frequent any english speaking communities other than HN, so I don't think it's a matter of an ingroup dialect, just a bit of focus is enough.
is what he means. The phrasing is a bit of an idiom and isn't meant to be taken literally.
Anyways I kinda like the flippant(?) tone of the OP, wonder if there's a better term to describe this type of writing. Best I can think of is "halfway between image-board speak and casual speech".
I like it.
Maybe Grok would be better. It's halfway there, already.
"Terminally online"?
Maybe it's a frog in a slowly heated water kind of thing, me being the frog, AI the slow heat.
Majestic refers to https://majestic.com, "backlink analysis".
Tranco (from Gemini): "Tranco is a research-oriented, manipulation-hardened top one million website ranking list designed to fix reproducibility and methodological flaws in older popularity metrics like Alexa."
The other... No idea.
A well-known web security journalist, who writes in this mode, is Brian Krebs of https://krebsonsecurity.com/.
This type of ingestigative web-security writing has three audiences:
- the "general" audience of non-security-focused IT professionals, who are nevertheless interested in security topics from afar;
- the "professional" audience of other web-security professionals, who do the exact same kinds of investigations the author themselves does (whether or not they then share their results publicly);
- and the "oppositional" audience, i.e. the very malicious-actor groups the investigations target.
Each article thus serves three purposes:
1. to the "general" audience, the article provides an entertaining and informative journalistic narrative (and this encourages this group to spread the article, to increase the likelihood people in the other two groups will read it);
2. to the "professional" audience, the article serves as an "investigation log" that must provide enough information to reproduce the derived information (so that the results can be trusted and acted upon), and/or so that the investigation can be taken further without wasting time doing things that have already been done (because each piece like this, if it doesn't end in the investigation target being cleaned up, serves double-duty as an invitation for collaboration, either directly, or via encouraging independent "federated investigations");
3. to the "oppositional" audience, the article acts as propaganda for the power and reach of the "side" of the investigators, with the intent of producing chilling effects against others doing the same thing; and, more specifically to would-be collaborators with the target group, acts to scare them off from doing that, cutting off the target group's resources.
Note the three-way conflict-of-interest this introduces: security professionals need to know how and where you got your information; general audiences don't really care and just find such info to be needless detail; and your investigation targets should ideally know as little as possible about these tools, so that they don't start enacting countermeasures to make these tools useless against them. (But it's good that the opposition is aware that these tools exist and understand the chain of inputs and outputs that goes through them -- to show exactly the sloppiness that got them got, and so prove that web security people are not just bluffing about having such powerful tools while actually parallel-reconstructing info they get via e.g. double-agents.)
This conflict-of-interest is mostly resolved by just naming these tools while describing them as little as possible, and absolutely never linking to them.
Security professionals are expected to recognize the names and know how to get access to them (if they don't have it already); general audiences are expected to just gloss over these names as some kind of technobabble (an expectation you and I, being curious-by-nature people, failed); and the opposition is expected to recognize that these tools exist, but either struggle to find them (these tools are often referred to by nicknames that are also names of larger services in other domains, so just punching the tool's name into google often does nothing), or struggle to get access to them. (With a specific additional goal of minimizing the knowledge the opposition has of these tools so that they can't socially-engineer their way into convincing some bureaucratic employer that they "should" be given access to them. Which means never describing how these tools work, providing screenshots of them, etc.)
1: https://x.com/DustinGouker/status/1996994845844582665
"The president of agalmic.holdings.root.184.97.AB5 is agalmic.holdings.root.184.97.201. The secretary is agalmic.holdings.root.184.D5, and the chair is agalmic.holdings.root.184.E8.FF. All the shares are owned by those companies in equal measure, and I can tell you that their regulations are written in Python. Have a nice day, now!"
https://www.antipope.org/charlie/blog-static/fiction/acceler...
Interestingly, it predicted the presence of mass AI robocall scams targeting the elderly almost a couple decades before it happened.
Not much of that going around these days.
Go soak in some culture, music videos and such, from the era. I watched the video for Beck's "Sex Laws" recently, and was overcome with the realization of what a hopeful time it actually was. The 1990s idea of a dystopia was something like Ellis' Transmetropolitan, a dystopia that looks frankly awesome as hell, in retrospect.
Unfortunately, in 2001 the boomers were still very firmly keeping their lead-brain-addled grip on the tiller, and they set a course straight for national disaster. As Osama predicted they would. But did he realize that would be handing the keys directly to the Chinese? Oops? Whelp that's the problem with extremism - it gives you tunnel vision of the worst sort.
[1] Perhaps it is a different shade[a] of the same feeling that even older people of a certain culture have for the pre-Desegregation era. "Let me tell ya back before all that stuff things were a lot nicer. . . "
[1.a] Different shade, except Evil.
We could still get the Gibsonesque "AI fighting for control" plot though. Perhaps in January, the Democrats could rebrand ICE as the Turing Police. Not that I'm in favor of that, but at least it would be more interesting.
It could be an interesting way to observe if certain crawlers are obeying robots headers by analysing scraped content, or could just be some element on the page itself and part of turnstile.
If it was registered by the Cloudflare team, they might explain why.
Something interesting is that the domain was unregisters for a very long time after it was referred to.
- It was in Majestic's top 10,000 in since October 5th before peaking to 8 recently.
- It was unregistered for almost that entire duration. Someone in Arkansas (self-reported WHOIS address) bought it through Cloudflare on Nov 11, and it still doesn't point anywhere. Could be a different person who noticed it was popular and bought it.
- About 250M links come from roughly 5M sites, including thousands of .edu and .gov sites. Nearly all are nofollow and on inner pages.
- Majestic's top link texts are the Chinese "打开这个网站 →" ("open this website →") and "↗ (opens the site in a new tab)". And about 67% of linking pages are in English. Suggests the links were of Chinese origin, not written by the sites themselves. And perhaps site rules dictated noreferrer.
- The count is now falling, and 23% of the links are already deleted, so it's being cleaned up (deleting forum posts?).
That leaves:
5.2M linking sites, nearly all nofollow, mostly on inner pages, many repeated within a site, about 21K .edu and .gov domains, and a falling total.
Semrush did show recently created links. Those were on spammy looking sites akin to 1289371298.xyz with copy like "education site link building" which sounds like it's just referring to a sketchy SEO practice of getting quality referrers. I think those websites are basically echoing the signal as well - they just find links that are common. Not the original source.
The weirdest part is that it was unregistered for so long. Was that a mistake? Was the w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a domain name a mistake?
I think those websites are basically echoing the signal as well though - they just find links that are common. Not the original source.
An internal experiment of majestic
edit: Not definitive but a potential signal
> The default assignment method is to use standard nameservers and favor consistent nameserver names across all zones within an account. Nonetheless, in case there are conflicts, you may get different nameserver names, even for domains that are within the same account.
https://developers.cloudflare.com/dns/nameservers/nameserver...
Not definitively. There are only so many pairs, many tens of thousands of customers probably call the same set home.
Before quitting ad-tech, I determined that, with IP addresses being hidden (eg the way Private Relay does), something like a large DNS backmap would be the only way to effectively determine that a visitor was a returning one across network sessions, because you need some signal that the user does or does not already "know" the destination on their first visit. At that point, it's kind of up to the DNS servers (esp the ns) to determine if this is abuse or not; but if they allow it, you can get a reasonable proxy for IP identity.
I don't have any good solutions in terms of maintaining privacy, except the known existing one, and how it's already supposed to work (which would have made hiding IPs unnecessary in the first place). I'm afraid it's too technical for most people who just want to connect and watch YouTube shorts or whatever: federated trust, with each smaller subset refusing to link through to any identifying information about their subset of users.
Feel free to DM me if you've got a job for me to help make it happen. I've got plenty of other valuable work to keep me busy, but I'd be interested to know if someone is working on this problem.
With the 'w' and the '1' in there it doesn't look like base 32.
So "Some loophole/gaming the rankings".
Caveats: this article is a reaction to the jack.cab post, not earlier than it. It also repeats itself a lot in a slop-like manner, so it might just be some LLM's answer.
I tried a few wordlists to see if any word matched those md5 (rockyou.txt) but didn't match anything.
[Scrolls back up again]
No way
Though the Discord one isn't fully responsive. It overflow on mobile.
Especially the Twitter "video". It's all CSS!
What the fuck is w2rt6byl5nf1opmc-a.com?
Seriously. We're on this website, a website frequented by all kinds of experts at internet infrastructure companies: ISPs, CDNs, Google, Cloudflare.
Consider this your Official Monday Morning Coffee Nerdsnipe. I expect an answer on my desk by the end of the day.
And then it hit me that I've been coming to this web site for seventeen years and that things change over time.
And I'll admit, society as a whole seems to have taken a turn for the worse in this department. There was a time when merely being online was something of a filter, and knowing about HN definitely was. Alas, walls being free is a special case. They usually have to be built. In the absence of catechesis, creed, peer review, editorial board, secret handshake, something, the masses draw a culture to the mean.
Edit: In the hour since I last looked, the intelligent crowd I expected seems to be showing up in force. Perhaps it was a fluke. I'll put away my doomsday sign about how the robots and the zombies are coming. They are, though.
> I could probably figure out what’s happening here in 30 seconds by buying a Majestic subscription but I’m lazy.
They're not interested in spending money on this. I wouldn't be either.
If he could solve this in 30 seconds, it's not exactly lazy to then do the hours-long investigation he did.
He's joking about being lazy, because he's being cheap.
Also, there's nothing wrong with using "laziness" as a motivator for making things more efficient, as long as you're doing it right, however "childish" you consider that wording.
It also could be an experiment to see how classic search engines and AI search handle ranking websites who’s main backlink profile is no-follow. Actually this is probably the most likely explanation, it also explains why they didn’t even register it and put content, they wanted to see how a domain ranks from those no follow links and didn’t want the content to pollute the signal.
Something something throwing stones something something glass houses.
Unless your perception is the trivial case (e.g. Ashby's law or categorical empty interpretations) I'd be very interested to know why our linguistic experience differs so much.
The endless, unexplained slang didn't help as well. There is no structure, no nothing. Is it still better than ai slop? You bet.